As talk and activity around Diversity, Equity and Inclusion increases in the charity/not for profit sector – we need key indicators, targets and timescales to measure change and hold ourselves and each other to account.
The Institute of Fundraising’s Manifesto for Change/Change Collective Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Strategy is a good example of how it might look www.institute-of-fundraising.org.uk/library/change-strategy/
For the Trust and Foundation sector we need indicators and targets covering, as a minimum, our governance, staffing, funding and investments. Which communities and types of organisations are getting funded? Who leads our organisations and who gets to make funding decisions? How do our endowments actively generate social justice rather than just an annual income for our organisation?
For those of us in Trusts and Foundations, we all have points of opportunity to create positive change:
- As individuals – what power do we have and how can we use it to make way and shift the power?
- As organisations – what are we doing to change a status quo that unfairly advantages some – including ourselves – and disadvantages others?
- As networks – how are we using – and expanding – our networks to learn, coordinate and collaborate better?
- As systems participants – how are we using our position in the complex political, social, economic, technological and organisational ecology that underpins our society – in order to advance social justice?
We need indicators and targets under each of those points so that we can honestly assess how much we have done to advance social equity – and racial justice in particular – over the next 3 years.
We also need specific actions that we can take under each of those points of opportunity. For example – as individuals:
- All white male charity board Chairs over the age of 40 need an ‘Exit Plan’ that will see them identify, mentor and hand over to a replacement /successor who has the required attributes to be a successful Chair and who doesn’t look like them – within 2 years from now. A framework for ‘Exit Plans’ should be developed by the Association of Chairs.
- All white male charity Chief Execs over the age of 40 need a ‘Creating the Competition’ plan that will see them identify, mentor and promote potential rivals for their next job over the next 2 years – rivals who don’t look like them. A framework for ‘Creating the Competition Plans’ should be developed by ACEVO.
- All white male charity Finance Directors/Managers and Treasurers need to compile a ‘Funding Diversity, Equity and Inclusion’ playbook which they will use to embed DEI in budget setting, financial reporting and performance management across their organisation by the end of the next financial year. A ‘Funding Diversity, Equity and Inclusion’ playbook should be developed by the Charity Finance Group.
Make Way And Shift The Power means we can all use whatever power and privilege we each have to make ways for change to happen. For other suggestions see this older blogpost:
Magic Wand Not Required
To increase diversity in the governance and management of trusts and foundations there are many actions that we as individuals, organisations and networks can take. Some of them require significant investment of time and/or money – but most of them just require the will of individuals to invest their own time – and share or give up some of their own power – to make a change.
To really make a change in this area – after years of little progress which is documented here: https://newreciprocity.com/2019/03/13/inertia-a-timeline-updated more radical solutions are needed. For example:
Chief Exec 1% Challenge:
All current Chief Execs and senior managers earning £50k or more should personally donate £500 to a Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Program (which should be coordinated by the Association of Charitable Foundations and be overseen by a diverse steering group) with individual foundations topping up as necessary. Ideally, this would arise from and be linked to ACF’s Stronger Foundations programme which includes a DEI strand.
The first thing it should do is to commission 3 law firms (charity and employment specialists) to give a pro bono consensus opinion on exactly how widely and radically we can use positive action.
It should then see what it can learn from others who have already taken a lead in this area – including:
Institute of Fundraising: https://www.institute-of-fundraising.org.uk/guidance/equality-diversity-inclusion/
Diversity Forum: http://www.diversityforum.org.uk/
Equality and Diversity Forum: http://www.edf.org.uk/
Understanding and Using All Motivators:
As well as the values-based and practical reasons for increasing Diversity and improving Inclusion to increase Equity, and the legal and regulatory reasons (some of which are detailed here: https://newreciprocity.com/2018/08/29/whats-the-point-of-diversity-equity-and-inclusion/) – change can also be brought about by other means – including incentives. For example, role modelling (by leaders and organisations), demonstrating increased competitive advantage and celebrating progress and achievements – eg:
People Pipeline Programmes: Funders should invest in programs which provide targeted, free or subsidised opportunities for people from under-represented communities to develop skills and experience relevant to roles in the trust and foundation sector. For example:
2027 Talent Programme – http://2027.org.uk/
This investment should be both by supporting the development of such initiatives (eg through core funding) and by paying for their own staff to participate in such initiatives.
Own Time Mentoring: Those currently in senior positions may not be able to afford to “make way” for people from under-represented groups. But they can do more to create other opportunities – eg mentoring (in their own time) the next generation of diverse leaders. If every one of us “majority community” leaders of trusts and foundations mentored someone from a “minority community” – imagine how much they’d learn. The ‘majority community’ leaders I mean.
There are already many mentoring schemes in the public and commercial sectors to learn from – and also some examples of voluntary sector organisations investing in developing their staff through such schemes:
Waiting for the trust and foundation sector to develop its own mentoring scheme is not sufficient. Individual foundation leaders should identify people to mentor – either from within their own organisations or from outside. If they don’t already have links or networks which will help them identify such people – then they should start using Twitter and other social media to find potential candidates – actively seeking out and following people with backgrounds and experiences different from their own:
Dead Men’s Shoes: Senior appointments in Trusts and Foundations are currently secure “dead men’s shoes” roles. In future, senior appointments (Director/CEO, etc) should be on a fixed term basis (eg 5 years) to ensure there is sufficient churn to enable people who aren’t older white men to get the opportunity to move into senior roles. Fixed term contracts are common in other sectors (eg the police, NHS and academia) and are also used by some foundations in the US.
Make Way: But that’s not enough. To prevent a merry-go-round of the same men moving from role to role, the supply of people from other backgrounds and attributes needs to be significantly improved (see Increasing Supply above).
Don’t take a trustee role if you’re male, middle aged and white – and you look like most of the board you’d be joining. Find a different way to volunteer or contribute – just not in a leadership/governance role. Unpaid advisory roles, frontline volunteering work, etc – there are lots of ways of “giving back”.
Not the Usual Suspects: And your own organisation should also be moving beyond the “golf club network” method of recruiting trustees. There is already a huge amount of guidance on how to recruit paid and volunteer staff – including trustees. For example: https://knowhownonprofit.org/your-team/hr/equality-and-diversity
But there remains a “supply-side” problem which needs to be addressed by initiatives that support the development of people from “non-traditional” backgrounds and communities into governance roles – for example: https://www.boardapprentice.com/
If you’re a male leader of a trust or foundation you should refuse to sit on any men only panels. If you’re a white leader of a trust or foundation you should refuse to sit on any white people only panels. http://www.owen.org/pledge
If you’re offered the excuse “there’s no one qualified” you should challenge it and find someone who is qualified to take your place. Mandy Johnson’s list of female speakers is a good place to start. https://greatcharityspeakers.com/the-list-so-far/
More ideas will be added to this list over time. Suggestions welcomed.
Based on the original post: https://newreciprocity.com/2018/03/05/makewayandshiftthepower/